FoodRef · Recipe

Asparagus, Potato & Cheddar Frittata

4/ 10Mediocre
Median across 11 diets

3 approve · 3 caution · 5 avoid

Controversy2.1
Consensus2.1Divisive

Standard deviation of the 11 scores. Higher = the diets disagree more.

The verdicts

Disapprove (5)

  • Vegan
    1.5
  • Carnivore
    2.5
  • Keto
    3.5
  • Low-FODMAP
    3.5
  • Whole30
    3.0

Caution (3)

  • DASH
    6.8
  • Paleo
    4.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory
    6.8

Approve (3)

  • Mediterranean
    7.5
  • Zone
    7.0
  • GLP-1
    7.2

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Heat the grill to high. Put the potatoes in a pan of cold salted water and bring to the boil. Once boiling, cook for 4-5 mins until nearly tender, then add the asparagus for a final 1 min. Drain.
  2. Meanwhile, heat the oil in an ovenproof frying pan and add the onion. Cook for about 8 mins until softened.
  3. Mix the eggs with half the cheese in a jug and season well. Pour over the onion in the pan, then scatter over the asparagus and potatoes. Top with the remaining cheese and put under the grill for 5 mins or until golden.

Diet-by-diet

DASHCaution

Mostly vegetables, eggs, and olive oil with minimal sodium added; cheddar adds some saturated fat and salt but overall portions are moderate.

MediterraneanApproved

Strong Mediterranean profile with olive oil, vegetables, eggs, and modest cheese; rocket side adds greens.

VeganAvoid

Contains eggs and cheddar cheese, which are animal products and disqualifying for vegans.

CarnivoreAvoid

Predominantly plant-based ingredients (potatoes, asparagus, onion, rocket) with only eggs and cheese as animal foods.

PaleoCaution

Eggs, asparagus, onion, and olive oil are paleo-friendly, but white potatoes are debated and cheddar cheese is not paleo.

KetoAvoid

Potatoes push carbs well above keto limits; eggs and cheese are keto-friendly but the dish overall is too starchy.

Low-FODMAPAvoid

Onion is high-FODMAP and a significant trigger; asparagus is also high-FODMAP, making this unsuitable as written.

Whole30Avoid

Eggs, vegetables, and olive oil comply, but cheddar cheese and white potatoes (allowed in newer Whole30 but dairy disqualifies) break compliance.

ZoneApproved

Reasonable balance of protein (eggs, cheese), carbs (potatoes, asparagus), and fat (olive oil, cheese) close to Zone ratios.

Olive oil, asparagus, onion, and leafy greens are anti-inflammatory; cheddar adds some saturated fat but overall favorable.

GLP-1Approved

High protein from eggs and cheese plus fiber from vegetables supports satiety; modest portion size and balanced macros align well.

Share this recipe