FoodRef

FoodRef · Scanned Plate

Tuna salad with spinach, onion and pumpkin seeds

6.4/ 10Mixed
Average across 11 diets

8 approve · 0 caution · 3 avoid

Controversy7.0Divided
Consensus7.0Divisive

Cheferee's Consensus

Mediterranean and DASH and Paleo rate this plate highest, Vegan and Carnivore lowest — a 7.8-point spread. They are not reading different evidence; they are applying different rules to the same plate.

What each diet says

Each score is that framework's own position on this plate, scored as a whole meal — not the average of its parts.

DASHApproved8.5

Lean tuna, leafy spinach, onions and seeds hit DASH's priorities of low-sodium protein and potassium-rich vegetables, though canned tuna adds some sodium.

MediterraneanApproved8.8

Oily fish, dark leafy greens, alliums and seeds are textbook Mediterranean components; only missing olive oil and a whole grain to be a perfect fit.

VeganAvoid1.0

Canned tuna is an animal product and takes up 35% of the plate, which categorically violates veganism regardless of the plant sides.

CarnivoreAvoid1.0

Spinach, both onions and pumpkin seeds together make up 65% of the plate — all plants, which carnivore strictly excludes.

PaleoApproved8.5

Fish, vegetables and seeds are all paleo-approved whole foods with no grains, dairy or legumes on the plate.

KetoApproved8.0

Very low-carb overall — tuna and spinach are near-zero carb, with only modest carbs from the onions and seeds, keeping it well within ketogenic range.

Low-FODMAPAvoid2.0

Red and white onion together are 30% of the plate and are among the highest-FODMAP foods possible, making this plate a clear trigger.

Whole30Approved7.5

All components — tuna, spinach, onions, pumpkin seeds — are Whole30-compliant assuming the tuna has no additives and the spinach was sautéed in an approved fat.

ZoneApproved8.5

Lean protein from tuna with low-glycemic vegetables and a small dose of seed fats is close to Zone's 40/30/30 protein-carb-fat balance.

Anti-InflammatoryApproved8.5

Omega-3-rich tuna, polyphenol-rich onions, spinach and zinc/magnesium from pumpkin seeds all actively support an anti-inflammatory pattern.

GLP-1Approved8.2

High protein from tuna plus fiber from spinach, onions and seeds supports satiety and gentle digestion, though the volume is on the smaller side for a full GLP-1 meal.

Food by food

Our catalog scores for each item. The plate's score above is a judgment on the whole meal, so it will not match the average of these.

Tuna (canned in water)~35% of the plate4.7▾
  • Keto6.0
  • Whole308.0
  • Vegan1.0
  • Paleo5.0
  • Mediterranean8.0
  • Carnivore6.0
  • Low-FODMAP8.0
  • DASH8.0
  • Zone8.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory8.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly8.0
See the full page for Tuna (canned in water) →
Red onion~20% of the plate7.0▾
  • GLP-1 Friendly8.0
  • Zone5.0
  • Paleo9.0
  • DASH8.0
  • Mediterranean9.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory8.0
  • Vegan10.0
  • Low-FODMAP1.0
  • Keto5.0
  • Carnivore1.0
  • Whole3010.0
See the full page for Red onion →
Spinach~25% of the plate5.5▾
  • Vegan10.0
  • Paleo9.0
  • Mediterranean9.0
  • Carnivore1.0
  • Whole3010.0
  • Low-FODMAP9.0
  • DASH10.0
  • Zone10.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory9.0
  • Keto10.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly9.0
See the full page for Spinach →
Pumpkin seeds~10% of the plate4.8▾
  • Keto8.0
  • Vegan9.0
  • Paleo8.0
  • Mediterranean8.0
  • Carnivore1.0
  • Whole308.0
  • Low-FODMAP8.0
  • DASH8.0
  • Zone5.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory8.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly8.0
See the full page for Pumpkin seeds →
White onion~10% of the plate7.0▾
  • Low-FODMAP1.0
  • Zone5.0
  • Paleo9.0
  • Mediterranean9.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory8.0
  • Vegan10.0
  • Keto5.0
  • Carnivore1.0
  • Whole3010.0
  • DASH9.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly7.0
See the full page for White onion →

Share this plate

At a restaurant? Scan the menu · Have a recipe? Scan the recipe

Scores describe what each named diet framework's published principles say about this food. They are not FoodRef's opinion on whether anything is healthy, and they are not medical or nutritional advice. Talk to a doctor or a registered dietitian about your own diet.

If tracking or rating food is difficult for you, support is available from the National Alliance for Eating Disorders. FoodRef keeps no daily totals, no streaks, and no scan history.