FoodRef

FoodRef · Scanned Plate

Roast chicken with potatoes and mixed vegetables

5.7/ 10Mixed
Average across 11 diets

7 approve · 0 caution · 4 avoid

Controversy6.4Divided
Consensus6.4Divisive

Cheferee's Consensus

Whole30 and DASH and Mediterranean rate this plate highest, Vegan and Carnivore lowest — a 7.5-point spread. They are not reading different evidence; they are applying different rules to the same plate.

What each diet says

Each score is that framework's own position on this plate, scored as a whole meal — not the average of its parts.

DASHApproved8.2

This plate is roughly half vegetables plus lean-ish poultry and unprocessed starches, with no added salt-heavy sauces indicated — very close to the DASH template. The chicken leg skin adds some saturated fat, keeping it from a perfect score.

MediterraneanApproved8.0

Lots of vegetables, whole-food starches, and poultry as the protein fit the Mediterranean pattern well. It loses a little ground because the fat source is roast chicken rather than olive oil, and there's no fish, legumes, or whole grains.

VeganAvoid1.0

Roast chicken leg quarters make up about 30% of the plate, which is an outright exclusion for veganism regardless of the vegetable sides.

CarnivoreAvoid1.0

Carnivore forbids all plant foods, and about 70% of this plate is potatoes, sweet potato, mushrooms, broccoli, peas and brussels sprouts. The chicken alone can't rescue it.

PaleoApproved7.8

Roast chicken, mushrooms, broccoli, brussels sprouts, and sweet potato are all paleo staples, and there are no grains, dairy or legumes-except-peas. Green peas are technically a legume, which is the only real deduction.

KetoAvoid2.5

With roasted potatoes, sweet potato, and peas together making up roughly 38% of the plate, the carb load is far too high for ketosis, even with the fatty chicken leg.

Low-FODMAPAvoid3.5

Sautéed mushrooms and roasted sweet potato in these portions are high-FODMAP, and brussels sprouts and green peas add more fructans and GOS. The chicken, potatoes and broccoli portions are fine, but the combination is problematic.

Whole30Approved8.5

Every item here — roast chicken, potatoes, sweet potato, mushrooms, broccoli, peas, brussels sprouts — is Whole30-compliant as described, with no grains, dairy, legumes-except-peas-are-borderline, or added sugar. Whole30 explicitly allows white potatoes and peas, so this fits cleanly.

ZoneApproved7.0

Protein from the chicken leg is solid, and the carbs come from mostly low-glycemic vegetables plus some denser starch. The 40/30/30 balance is decent but the combined potato and sweet potato push carbs a bit high relative to protein.

Anti-InflammatoryApproved7.8

Broccoli, brussels sprouts, mushrooms, sweet potato, and peas provide a strong load of polyphenols, fiber and carotenoids, with poultry as a moderate protein. The chicken skin's saturated fat and lack of omega-3 sources keep it from a top score.

GLP-1Approved7.5

Portion is reasonable, protein is adequate at ~30% of the plate, and fiber is high from the vegetable mix, all of which support GLP-1 goals. The starch load from potatoes plus sweet potato is a bit heavy for optimal satiety-per-calorie.

Food by food

Our catalog scores for each item. The plate's score above is a judgment on the whole meal, so it will not match the average of these.

Chicken~30% of the plate5.5
  • Paleo9.0
  • Zone9.0
  • Mediterranean6.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory7.0
  • DASH9.0
  • Carnivore8.0
  • Vegan1.0
  • Whole3010.0
  • Keto9.0
  • Low-FODMAP10.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly9.0
See the full page for Chicken
Potato~18% of the plate7.0
  • Carnivore1.0
  • Paleo5.0
  • Zone2.0
  • DASH8.0
  • Whole309.0
  • Mediterranean8.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory5.0
  • Vegan10.0
  • Keto1.0
  • Low-FODMAP9.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly5.0
See the full page for Potato
Mushrooms~15% of the plate4.5
  • Keto8.0
  • Vegan9.0
  • Mediterranean8.0
  • Whole309.0
  • Low-FODMAP5.0
  • DASH8.0
  • Zone8.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory9.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly8.0
  • Paleo8.0
  • Carnivore2.0
See the full page for Mushrooms
Sweet potato~13% of the plate7.2
  • Keto1.0
  • Vegan10.0
  • Paleo8.0
  • Mediterranean8.0
  • Carnivore1.0
  • Whole309.0
  • Low-FODMAP8.0
  • DASH9.0
  • Zone2.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory8.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly5.0
See the full page for Sweet potato
Broccoli~12% of the plate5.4
  • Keto9.0
  • Vegan10.0
  • Paleo9.0
  • Mediterranean9.0
  • Carnivore1.0
  • Whole3010.0
  • Low-FODMAP9.0
  • Zone9.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory9.0
  • DASH10.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly9.0
See the full page for Broccoli
Peas~7% of the plate6.2
  • Keto2.0
  • Vegan9.0
  • Paleo2.0
  • Mediterranean8.0
  • Whole301.0
  • Low-FODMAP2.0
  • DASH6.0
  • Zone5.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory7.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly6.0
  • Carnivore1.0
See the full page for Peas
Brussels sprouts~5% of the plate5.4
  • Keto8.0
  • Vegan9.0
  • Paleo9.0
  • Mediterranean8.0
  • Carnivore1.0
  • Whole309.0
  • Low-FODMAP5.0
  • Zone9.0
  • Anti-Inflammatory9.0
  • DASH9.0
  • GLP-1 Friendly9.0
See the full page for Brussels sprouts

Share this plate

At a restaurant? Scan the menu · Have a recipe? Scan the recipe

Scores describe what each named diet framework's published principles say about this food. They are not FoodRef's opinion on whether anything is healthy, and they are not medical or nutritional advice. Talk to a doctor or a registered dietitian about your own diet.

If tracking or rating food is difficult for you, support is available from the National Alliance for Eating Disorders. FoodRef keeps no daily totals, no streaks, and no scan history.